DIY Canister Filter? Worth My Time?


Topic: I want to upgrade my filter on my fish aquarium. I’ve been thinking about a diy canister filter. I’ve looked at some of the popular tutorial online. Wondering what your opinions on the idea are..? Building one versus buying one..?


 

*Awarded Answer
Posted by Kevin F: I absolutely love diy aquarium projects but the DIY canister filter is one I didn’t want to mess around with. If you really think about all the variables.. it just isn’t worth it! I know your thinking about “saving money” but hear me out on this! You can buy a SunSun canister filter for $30 to $50 on the cheap side. When you start adding up the cost of a pump and a couple of the accessories.. the price adds up faster than you think (when making your own filter).

IT IS NOT WORTH THE TIME!

When you add up all the headache your going to put into building a DIY canister filter.. and come to find out the actual cost is close to buying one anyways.. you will regret wasting your time. And YES I know this from experience. Buy this SunSun canister filter for around $50 and you will be much happier! Here is the link:

Pros:
1. Save Money
2. Build More Effective

Cons:
1. Pump is Expensive
2. Possible Leak in Your House!
3. Effectiveness Problems
4. Large Obnoxious Item

Companies have spent countless hours perfecting these filters. If you think you can do a better job… you will most likely be wrong (no offense). For the cost to build one you could probably buy a cheap brand new one. Here is a SunSun for under $100. This is probably the most sold canister filter on the planet!

The pumps alone to build things with are expensive! And then the media too. Then there is the worry of the diy project leaking all over your house.

Every project that I do like this for my aquariums never really goes as planned. The siphon feed doesn’t work like I planned… or the pump only works when submerged into water.. or the pump doesn’t push the water fast enough to keep up with the gravity feed. There is a lot that goes into this stuff. I do love it! But just expressing some variables that I weigh out whenever I want to build a canister filter.

 

 

 

More Related Questions:

  • Fishless cycling: Buy an api master test kit. Add 4 ppm of ammonia, either from ammonia bottle or flake food. Test your water every day for ammonia and nitrite. If ammonia goes down to 1 ppm then add ammonia to get it back to 4 ppm. Once you see nitrite, then you can start testing for nitrate. The nitrite indicates that you have the first set of beneficial bacteria. If you see your nitrite drop below 1 ppm then dose the ammonia to keep the nitrite at around 2 ppm. Once you have 20 ppm of nitrate then you have the second set of beneficial bacteria. Let the ammonia and nitrite go to zero and then do a 50 percent water change. Slowly add fish. It should take at least six weeks but the process will be much faster if you seed your filter with media from a cycled tank.
  • Hiii everyone, i have a frontosa cichlid along with some peacock cichlids in my tank. I want to improve the hump of the frontosa, but since there are peacocks with frontosa, so i am afraid to provide humpy head pellets. My question is if i provide humpy head and it is eaten by peacocks too, will it harm them?
  • Frontosa shouldn’t be kept with peacocks. The frontosa will eat the peacocks eventually.

    Fronts need to be in a colony of other frontosa in a 6′ tank and eventually an 8′ tank. They will teach 15-18″ as adults.
    Pick a healthy food not one made for a hump on their head. If dominant they will develop a Hump on their own.

    They are deep water open swimmers so the tank should have plenty of open swimming space and large openings for caves. The tank should have subdued lighting as bright lights will stress frontosa.

  • I’ve been breeding frontosa for 15 years and never heard of a food that is for the development of their hump. You just want a nice healthy high protein food. Frozen krill, krill pellets or frozen foods. I’ve used whiting fish, that I bought from the super market and cut into little chunks and thawed in tank water before feeding. Most males will get the nuchal hump as they get older.
  • You should not feed to promote the growth of nuchal humps. This is something that hybrid keepers do. Feed a good quality diet and they will reward you with excellent color and a fantastic natural appearance.

    Alex Ong we do not discuss live feeding in the group. Please refer to the group rules before posting again.

  • WTF IS THIS THING?!? I found it while I was doing a water change, it looks like some kind of tiny shrimp/lobster, or the water equivalent of an earwig? And ideas on what it is or what to do with it? Freshwater tropical aquarium.
  • Had a friend bring me a load of plants from her pond and one of my tanks ended up full of them! Scooped everyone out and had Lost three shrimp from them 🙁
  • if you have no fry sized fish you could watch it grow, but you would adventually have a damselfly in your house.
  • I want to attempt to set up a 10 gallon tank for my 4 year old sons bedroom and I want it to be avenger themed. I’ve search and searched for a background paper and have been unsuccessful. I thought about getting crafty and maybe trying to purchase a poster and taping it to tank or using modge podge to attach it to the tank. Good idea? Or does someone have another suggestion?
  • I spent nearly $2000 on backgrounds, mats and rocks for my 500 gallon and 340 gallon show aquariums from Aquadecor. I bought a G8 version which has (had) a lot of dark color. Was beautiful at first, but after less than 3 months the color has bleached out and I am stuck with a very disappointing, DIY level quality background. With the many hours needed to install the background, mats and rocks, i would not risk settling with Aquadecor on replacements, and repeat this nightmare again. I have attached pictures, in order,1) pic of background from their website 2) pic of pre-shipment 3) day after installation 4) background after 3 months. Has anybody else had this experience with Aquadecor products?